Loser Edition 2LP on Clear with Blue, Green & Purple Splatter Vinyl

This is the Loser Edition of Father John Misty's Greatish Hits: I Followed My Dreams and My Dreams Said to Crawl, two LPs pressed on clear vinyl run through with blue, green and purple splatter. The splatter falls differently on every copy, so no two sets look exactly alike. Seventeen tracks run across four sides, each record in a printed inner sleeve, and the runout etchings on all four sides point to a lacquer cut at Black Belt Mastering.

The center labels carry the full billing, Josh Tillman Presents Fr. John Misty's Greatish Hits, with production credited to Tillman himself. The jacket painting sends a lone rider, arrows in his back, through a field of giant glowing mushrooms under an aurora. Sub Pop's own notes open with a warning that the set features mostly old music and that long-time listeners risk a swindle.

The compilation came out digitally on July 31, 2024, with the physical editions following on August 16. It draws on all five Father John Misty albums, from Fear Fun (2012) and I Love You, Honeybear (2015) through the Grammy-nominated Pure Comedy (2017), God's Favorite Customer (2018) and Chloë and the Next 20th Century (2022). It also gives the 2016 single "Real Love Baby" its first place on an album.

The one new song closes side D. Tillman had played "I Guess Time Just Makes Fools of Us All" live as early as 2019 and through a run of 2023 shows before announcing its release to fans by text message through his newsletter. Pitchfork named it among 26 contenders for song of the summer, Esquire put it on its list of the best songs of 2024 so far, and it appeared again four months later on the studio album Mahashmashana.

Sub Pop puts Father John Misty's US sales at more than 1.1 million copies. The record is issued under exclusive license to Sub Pop Records, copyright 2024 Joshua Tillman.

Tracklist

Side A

1. Nancy From Now On
2. Disappointing Diamonds Are the Rarest of Them All
3. Chateau Lobby #4 (In C for Two Virgins)
4. Goodbye Mr. Blue
5. When You're Smiling and Astride Me

Side B

1. Mr. Tillman
2. Things It Would Have Been Helpful to Know Before the Revolution
3. Please Don't Die
4. I'm Writing a Novel

Side C

1. Real Love Baby
2. Buddy's Rendezvous
3. Total Entertainment Forever
4. Hollywood Forever Cemetery Sings
5. Holy Shit

Side D

1. Pure Comedy
2. I Love You, Honeybear
3. I Guess Time Just Makes Fools of Us All

Our Shipping Terms

Evergreen Vinyl ships records with care and attention to detail, using established carriers and packaging practices designed to protect physical media in transit.

Where We Ship

We currently ship to the United States and Canada.

Order Processing

Orders are typically processed and shipped within 1–3 business days after payment is received. Orders placed on weekends or holidays are processed on the next business day.

Pre-orders generally ship on or around the official release date of the title. When available, estimated ship timing is noted on the product page.

Carriers

We ship via USPS, UPS, or FedEx, depending on destination, package size, and service availability. Carrier selection is made at the time of fulfillment.

Shipping Speeds & Delivery Estimates

Delivery timelines are estimates, not guarantees.

Estimated delivery windows are quoted at checkout based on the shipping speed you select and your delivery address. Transit time begins after your order has been processed.

Typical delivery within the United States ranges from 3–7 business days after shipment, depending on location and selected service. Delivery times for Canada vary by destination and carrier, and may be affected by customs processing.

While most deliveries arrive within the quoted window, occasional delays may occur due to weather, carrier volume, or other factors outside our control.

Shipping Rates

Shipping costs are calculated and displayed at checkout based on destination, package weight, and selected delivery speed.

Signature Requirements

Orders totaling over $250 may require a signature upon delivery to help ensure safe receipt. This is applied based on order value and carrier guidelines.

Tracking & Safe Delivery

Once your order ships, you’ll receive tracking information via email. We recommend monitoring tracking updates and ensuring delivery to a secure location.

Evergreen Vinyl is not responsible for packages that are lost or stolen after being marked as delivered by the carrier. Customers are responsible for selecting a shipping address where deliveries can be received safely.

If a shipment is delayed, missing, or marked as delivered but not received, we’re happy to assist in coordinating with the carrier.

Canadian Orders

Canadian customers are responsible for any applicable duties, taxes, or import fees assessed at delivery.

Damaged Shipments

If your order arrives with visible damage:

• Please retain all packaging, including the outer box and packing materials

• Contact us as soon as possible (ideally immediately) after delivery

• Clear photos of the item and packaging may be required to support a carrier claim

Prompt reporting allows us to resolve issues more efficiently and advocate on your behalf.

Questions or Shipping Issues

For shipping-related questions or concerns, please contact us at:

info@evergreenvinyl.com

We care about getting this right and will always aim for a fair, reasonable resolution.

Last updated: 2/6/26

Returns & Refunds

Evergreen Vinyl takes care in how records and equipment are described, graded, packed, and shipped. If something arrives in a condition that isn’t right, we want to address it promptly and fairly.

Returns

We accept returns only for items that arrive damaged, defective, or incorrect, or where a return has been approved in advance.

To be eligible for a return:

• You must contact us within 7 days of delivery

• Items must be unused and unplayed

• Items must be returned in their original packaging

• Photos of the issue may be required prior to approval

We do not accept returns for:

• Buyer’s remorse or accidental orders

• Opened or played records

• Minor corner dings, seam splits, or cosmetic wear caused during shipping

• Items damaged after delivery

• Items marked final sale

Exchanges

We offer exchanges for new, unopened products only, subject to availability.

• Exchanges must be approved in advance

• The customer is responsible for return shipping costs

• Items must be returned in original, unopened condition

Used items are not eligible for exchange.

Used Records & Grading Expectations

Used records are graded carefully and honestly, but they are not perfect.

If the media or sleeve is graded below New or Mint, cosmetic or playback-related imperfections should be expected and are reflected in the price and description. These characteristics do not qualify as defects.

Turntables & Speakers

Turntables and speakers are non-returnable once delivered unless they arrive damaged or defective.

If an issue is present on arrival:

• Contact us within 7 days of delivery

• Retain all original packaging and accessories

• Provide clear photos and a description of the issue

We will review the issue and, when approved, arrange a replacement or refund in accordance with this policy.

Merchandise & Accessories

Merchandise and accessories (including, but not limited to, apparel, slipmats, accessories, and non-media items) are final sale and non-returnable, unless they arrive damaged or incorrect.

Damaged, Defective, or Incorrect Items

If your order arrives damaged, defective, or incorrect:

• Please retain all original packaging, including the outer box and packing materials

• Contact us as soon as possible (ideally immediately) after delivery

• Include your order number, a brief description of the issue, and clear photos

Prompt reporting allows us to resolve issues efficiently and, when applicable, pursue carrier claims.

Refunds

Approved refunds are issued to the original payment method after inspection (if a return is required).

• Original shipping costs are non-refundable unless the error was ours

• Refund timing may vary depending on your payment provider

Chargebacks & Payment Disputes

We strongly encourage customers to contact us directly with any concerns before filing a credit card dispute or chargeback.

Once a dispute or chargeback has been initiated, we are unable to proceed with refunds, replacements, or reshipments until the case is fully resolved. Resolution timelines are controlled by the payment processor and can take up to 120 days.

Preorders

Preorders may be cancelled for a full refund at any time before the order ships.

Once a preorder has shipped, it is treated as a completed order and is subject to the return, refund, and exchange policies outlined above.

Non-Returnable Items

The following items are not eligible for return or refund unless they arrive damaged, defective, or incorrect:

• Merchandise and accessories

• Turntables and speakers

• Used records graded below New or Mint (for condition-related expectations)

Our Approach

Records and audio equipment are physical objects, and small variations can occur. We aim to be transparent, consistent, and reasonable. We take legitimate issues seriously when they arise.

Questions or Return Requests

For return, exchange, or refund questions, please contact us at:

info@evergreenvinyl.com

Including your order number helps us assist you more efficiently.

Last updated: 2/6/26